Why medieval city-builder video games are historically inaccurate - Leiden Medievalists Blog
-
relatively stable between the twelfth and the eighteenth century
Hm... wasn't there like a 33% dip back in the fourteenth, not counting subsequent migration to the cities and whatnot..?
I don't know, we need a medievalist here
-
Video games aren’t supposed to be realistic, they’re supposed to be fun
realistic is sometimes fun
-
Video games aren’t supposed to be realistic, they’re supposed to be fun
Simulator then?
-
This post did not contain any content.
This is a great article! It's really interesting.
I have two comments to make, and I hope nobody thinks this is me trying to disagree with the article or something, I don't want it to come across as defensive. In explaining some of the challenges medieval cities go through and saying Banished is a pretty accurate game, I think this might just be a genre issue. I consider Banished a colony management game, not a city builder, and indeed, in colony management games your people's health and safety are usually a much larger concern than in a city builder.
The second comment is that the writer suggests a game with flood mechanics and arable farm land. I don't remember if it was out in March of 2020, but Timberland is out now. It's a beaver based colony management game that includes a lot of fluid dynamics. It has flood mechanics like described. It's unrealistic, of course, because they're beavers. But also because flooding isn't the end of the world if it gets into your buildings, I think it's more of an inconvenience. Regardless, I think it's a cool game to check out.
-
Well, there was that little thing called the black death, if I recall correctly...
-
This is a great article! It's really interesting.
I have two comments to make, and I hope nobody thinks this is me trying to disagree with the article or something, I don't want it to come across as defensive. In explaining some of the challenges medieval cities go through and saying Banished is a pretty accurate game, I think this might just be a genre issue. I consider Banished a colony management game, not a city builder, and indeed, in colony management games your people's health and safety are usually a much larger concern than in a city builder.
The second comment is that the writer suggests a game with flood mechanics and arable farm land. I don't remember if it was out in March of 2020, but Timberland is out now. It's a beaver based colony management game that includes a lot of fluid dynamics. It has flood mechanics like described. It's unrealistic, of course, because they're beavers. But also because flooding isn't the end of the world if it gets into your buildings, I think it's more of an inconvenience. Regardless, I think it's a cool game to check out.
I am a big fan of Timberborn, but if we go all pedantic about it, Timberborn's flood mechanics aren't all that realistic.
A game that came somewhat close to realistic flood mechanics was Pharaoh/Cleopatra (1999/2000). Even though it used an abstract/statistical model (due to the technical limitations of the time), it felt a lot closer to reality than Timberborn even if there were some gamey elements like how well you respected Osiris.
-
Written in 2020 but still an interesting read. I wonder what the author thinks of games that have released in the intervening years, like Manor Lords, Going Medieval, and Farthest Frontier?
I am looking forward to Manor Lords when it gets released. Been tracking it for years.
-
Video games aren’t supposed to be realistic, they’re supposed to be fun
Sure, but exploring the way games abstract reality can be interesting and worthwhile.
-
I am a big fan of Timberborn, but if we go all pedantic about it, Timberborn's flood mechanics aren't all that realistic.
A game that came somewhat close to realistic flood mechanics was Pharaoh/Cleopatra (1999/2000). Even though it used an abstract/statistical model (due to the technical limitations of the time), it felt a lot closer to reality than Timberborn even if there were some gamey elements like how well you respected Osiris.
I'm not saying they're realistic, just that it has some of the flood/farming mechanics the blog author wanted to see in a game.
-
This post did not contain any content.
Default difficulty... Certain wiping out of every living being in your village, and failure. Conclusions in article are fairly poor as they are "games are already designed smartly, and there's nothing that should be changed."
A good game concept would be to put the player as a "middle manager" with feudal lord as the client. The mission is how to best oppress the villagers in order to graduate to better employment: managing a bigger city.
-
Well, there was that little thing called the black death, if I recall correctly...
Ah, yeah, there was, that's not how most of the time went, though
