What was your biggest movie let-down/disappointment ever?
-
For me it might be the Hobbit Trilogy.
The LotR Trilogy are my all time favorite movies and the contrast couldn't be greater. Really goes to show what a perfect storm it was that we got the movies we got with LotR.
The problem with the Hobbit movies was that they were too much like the Lord of the Rings movies.
-
It made me want to never re-watch the series, too. The pedophilic undercurrent to the movie makes parts of the show so, so, much worse.
-
For me it might be the Hobbit Trilogy.
The LotR Trilogy are my all time favorite movies and the contrast couldn't be greater. Really goes to show what a perfect storm it was that we got the movies we got with LotR.
There's a fan cut out there on the high seas, where they basically condensed those three shitty movies into one which follows the book as close as possible.
That one is bearable and as far as I am concerned the official Hobbit movie now. -
oh man I was so disapointed in the book compared to the moive. I feel crichton has great ideas but is not a good writer. It is one of the few writers where I prefer the movies.
There are always exceptions. Andromeda Strain was an excellent book.
-
original with Robin Williams or the reboot with The Rock?
I'm assuming the one with Rock
The one with Robin Williams, I had no expectations whatsoever for the one with The Rock. (When I wrote my comment, I didn't even remember that the remake existed so I didn't realize that it might have been useful to specify which one of them I meant.)
-
This post did not contain any content.
X-Men Phoenix - such a great grafic novel arch and solid movies before that flick. Phoenix writing and acting saddens me.
-
This post did not contain any content.
I Know What You Did Last Summer [2025]
Atrocious acting, annoying characters, terrible storyline and an abundance of plot holes! Literally nothing made sense. And in the process killing the legacy of the originals.
Worst reboot I ever saw. And there will probably be another sequel -_- -
Not saying you're wrong, but praising the giant robot attack on New York before swerving into critiquing the latter half of the movie for being ridiculous is a funny juxtaposition.
Here's the way I look at it.
A fictional story should follow its own rules. Let's take "The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly." The idea that someone would let himself be hung, trusting the other guy to be able to make that incredible shot over and over and never miss, is nonsensical. But we in the audience accept that premise for the sake of the story. We'd be disappointed if, halfway through the movie, an orchestra appears in the middle of the desert and they do a big musical number.
"Sky Captain" was ridiculous because of the way the story kept shifting and the rules kept changing.
-
easy one: Jurassic Park (1993)
I had read the book, maybe, a dozen times before the film came out, and holy shit was I disappointed. crushed, really. Not just in what they changed, but also what they left out. it totally ruined for me books adapted to film. any time I see a film based on a book I've read, I'm always let down.
Go find 'The Great Train Robbery'
Creighton directed the movie based on his own novel.
-
oh man I was so disapointed in the book compared to the moive. I feel crichton has great ideas but is not a good writer. It is one of the few writers where I prefer the movies.
Try reading "The Great Train Robbery."
He wrote it as if it were a factual reconstruction of an actual crime. Long passages on things like rat baiting, penny hangs, tipping servants, and other Victoriana
-
Arrival and Interstellar. Half baked cop out time travel shit
Look up a show called "The Lazarus Project."
Silly in places, but they do a fun take on the whole time travel thing.
-
There's a fan cut out there on the high seas, where they basically condensed those three shitty movies into one which follows the book as close as possible.
That one is bearable and as far as I am concerned the official Hobbit movie now.Any links to movie or group
-
This post did not contain any content.
Unpopular opinion for the cinephiles, it would be Stalker by Andrey Tarkovsky for me. It's overrated and it's just a bunch of guys talking. I wouldn't have mind the philosophical talks if it weren't for the pointless long shots that spanned for minutes. And it is not even clear if there is actually supernatural, or scifi or none of those.
-
Basically? It was a kids movie. Characters were one-dimensional and not very likeable to teenage me. Exposition by dialogue, and not great dialogue. Slapstick bits that really didn't land (Jar Jar). Etc, etc.
Even as a child when I first saw Phantom Menace, I thought it was off. Maybe I would have rated the film lower if it weren't for the fun pod racing segment and the fight with Darth Maul. I think the Star War prequel trilogy excel more on the editing and choreography of action scenes than actual story telling and drama.
-
And the originals weren't kids movies?
I guess the massive amount of Star Wars toys I had as a child somehow led me to believe otherwise.
Original trilogy are also kids movies, fight me.
The Empire Strikes Back is definitely not a kid's movie in my opinion. The Return of the Jedi is more kiddie because of Ewoks.
-
This post did not contain any content.
It's been a while, but that would be Sin City 2 for me. Back then I was young and naive, and didn't know that 99% of sequels are soulless cashgrabs. And I was really hyped, I loved the first one and still think of it as the best comic book adaptation I've ever seen. You could see the love in every frame.
-
My biggest problem with
thisthe sequels is that Luke's character just got completely butchered.You really want me to believe that one of my childhood heros, who against all odds, against his mentors judgement, decided to go all in on the "There's good in my father, I'll save him or die."-train would grow old and wants to kill his own fucking nephew because he's seeing something evil in him?
-
There are always exceptions. Andromeda Strain was an excellent book.
You know I do recall that one not being bad. Rising son was maybe a little better book wise to.
-
Try reading "The Great Train Robbery."
He wrote it as if it were a factual reconstruction of an actual crime. Long passages on things like rat baiting, penny hangs, tipping servants, and other Victoriana
I have not read that but I don't read much now so I doubt I will get around to it. Top of my list is reading the wheel of time that jordan did not write to finish off the series.
-
Any links to movie or group
I'm more of a usenet sailor, but the Pirate Bay seems to have "The Hobbit M4 Book Edit" available. It seems to be the most liked edit, although it is rather long, there are shorter ones available (see the linked post).
